SNOWFLAKES IN AUTUMN!

by Brian Bamford

THE pears are ripe early this year and are already falling from the trees in the orchards and it's only just Harvest Festival, yet in the political world of the 'loco left' the snowflakes are already drifting all around us.  Someone called Ms. Maria Beatrice Giovanardi has launched a petition online calling on the publisher of the Oxford  University Press to delete words which she, and 30,000 others who have signed the petition, regard as offensive to women.

According to a Daily Star editorial yesterday:  'They want all the slang terms for women banned from the English dictionary,  This includes words such as "bird" and "biddy".'

Logically the Daily Star editor argues:
'Of course there will be those who find terms like these offensive.  But many others - both men and women - will not. 

'And the simple fact is these words are part of our everyday language. 

'You can't start axing them just because they give a select few the hump.' 

The Star editor has a point, because to start axing everyday words would impoverish  the English language.

A nephew of mine has sought to keep certain concepts and words away from his children by strictly censoring the our language and utterances when his kids are anywhere near within earshot. 

The philosopher Ludwig Wittgenstein writes in Philosophical Investigations that the meaning of a word is its use in a language (Wittgenstein 1953, I, sec. 43):

'Words get their meaning by virtue of their relationships with other words and their use.'

Words are tools for expressing meaning in the everyday world.  Those with a schoolmaster mentality may not like that, and they may wish to control our use of language by some centralised diktat, but they will just have to lump it!

Yet the Snowflakes themselves are utterly naive if they think they can destroy disagreeable thoughts by expunging slang words they don't take a shine-to from the dictionaries; words are tools which we use to express our thoughts and meanings in the world.  Words exist independently of their dictionary definitions.  Indeed, Katherine Connor Martin from the Oxford University Press said in response to these detractors that a word 'will not be excluded from the dictionary solely on the grounds that it is offensive or derogatory', adding 'our dictionaries strive to reflect, rather than dictate language.'

Dictionaries in the natural course of things have to be constantly updated to keep up with changes in use of language.  In other words dictionaries follow the meanings and use in the real world, not the other way round.

***************

Lord Steel Nominated Shamed Rochdale MP for knighthood

Information Commissioner forces Government's hand in revelation of man behind Sir Cyril!

 

A Daily Star investigation has exposed that the former Liberal Party leader David Steel proposed Cyril Smith for a knighthood.  Smith, who was knighted in 1988 and who died in 2010, has now had his reputation become enmeshed in a a trail of child abuse scandals in Rochdale and beyond. 

 

The Liberal Democrat Party, that was formed out of the old Liberal Party, has said that it was not aware of Cyril Smith's crimes during his lifetime. 

 

Yet the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO), which has now compelled the Government to publish who nominated Smith for a knighthood, has said that while the full extent of Smith's activities were not known at the time of his nomination in 1988, 'there was quite widespread knowledge at that time that he was the subject of allegations'. 

 

In the latest issue of Northern Voices (NV14 - Summer/ Autumn 2013) a former editor of the Rochdale Alternative Paper (RAP) John Walker has written how in 1978/79 his 'small community magazine... decided to investigate what lay behind the rumours of the "Smith story" that had circulated in political circles in the town (Rochdale) for a decade.'  Mr. Walker continues:

'In the course of the six month investigation, the paper (RAP) interviewed more than 30 people, including seven former residents of Cambridge House, senior local politicians and police officers and council officials, all on an "off the record" basis, about (Cyril's) activities at the hostel.  Having had every word of the story they published libel-read by three independent sets of lawyers, ..., RAP published a 2,000 word account of (Smith's) sexual and physical abuse of teenage boys at Cambridge House.'

 

The RAP editors in 1979 then  sought the views of then leader of the Liberal Party, David Steel, and reply came from Steel's press secretary:

'It is not a very friendly gesture publishing that.  All he seems to have done is spanked a few bare bottoms.'

Well there you go!  Last Sunday's Daily Star repeated this quote and its journalist Jonathan Corke wrote:
'... last month the Information Commissioner's Office ruled that Mr Steel's involvement in recommending him for a knighthood should be made public.  The Cabinet Office, whose ministers include Lib Dems Nick Clegg and David Laws, spent more than six months trying to hide the revelation from us.'

It had been claimed disclosure would breach data protection rules but the ICO found that there was a 'legitimate public interest' in it being disclosed.

Tomorrow's Rochdale Observer quotes a Lib Dem 'spokesperson' as saying  'they were unaware Smith was a child abuser during his lifetime', and that 'His actions were not known or condoned by anyone in the Liberal Party or the Liberal Democrats'.  It is also alleged in the Rochdale Observer that 'Lord David Steel has always denied any knowledge of Smith's actions.'

Northern Voices has just received a response by e-mail to this above quote from John Walker, who together with David Bartlett in May 1979 edited the issue of RAP that broke the original story, and he now says:  'This is clearly misleading, at the very least.'

The blue plaque commemorating Cyril Smith was removed in 2012, but Rochdale Town Hall still apparently has a 'Cyril Smith room', and is it true that he is still a freeman of the borough of Rochdale?
_______________________________________________


A few copies of NORTHERN VOICES 14, are still on sale at some of our usual outlets with coverage of our role in the outing of Cyril Smith. John Walker, a former editor of RAP (the Rochdale Alternative Paper), in a leading feature documents the intimate story of Cyril Smith which was used as the basis of the Channel 4 documentary Dispatches last September on the eve of the Lib-Dem annual conference. Since he left RAP Mr. Walker has occasionally contributed to Private Eye, here he is flattering in his praise of N.V. and he writes of us 'being part of that long tradition of a radical press, that has never been afraid to call into question abuses of the powerful.' 

________________________________________________

The printed version of NORTHERN VOICES 14, may also be obtained as follows:
Postal subscription: £5 for the next two issues (post included)
Cheques payable to 'Northern Voices' sent to
Jim Petty,
c/o 52, Todmorden Road,
Burnley, Lancashire BB10 4AH.
Tel.: 0161 793 5122.
email: northernvoices@hotmail.com