by John Wilkins
I THOUGHT there needed to be a discussion about how people
interpreted nationalism as opposed to patriotism after campaigning in
the referendum last year. A member of the public did not agree with
my views he called me a traitor. This annoyed me as I could not see
why I could not be both patriotic and still stay in Europe. I told
him that my father, who was shot down over France a month before I
was born, could definitely be called a patriot.
The recent outburst on twitter by President Trump over the
'kneeling protests' by NFL players, seemed to echo the views and
anger shown by the right wing extremist I had met.
I was impressed by the calm and eloquent way Osi Umenyiora, ex NFL
star and tv pundit spoke on the subject prior to tv coverage of a
game. Osi is a Nigerian American who said he valued the opportunities
given him in the USA and claimed he would be prepared to give his
life for his adopted country. Commenting on Trump's tweet when he
referred to the protesters as
'sons of bitches', Osi said he did not
remember Trump using such language about white supremacists, one of
whom killed a woman and injured others by driving his car into the
counter protesters at a fascist rally in Charlottesville.
NFL players knelt for the national anthem in a respectful manner
to highlight the numbers of black lives that had been lost to police
violence.
The sport's national association issued a statement saying
'Sports
are a unifying influence in our society, bringing people of differing
backgrounds and beliefs together.' and
'Our respect for the
national anthem has always been a hallmark of our pre-match events.'
Osi claimed that Trump had behaved contrary to the values of the
founding fathers of the country with regard to the First Amendment of
the Constitution. This states there should be no
'abridging the
freedom of speech,.....or the right of the people peaceably to
assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of
grievances.' He therefore argues it is the President who is
unpatriotic in not upholding citizen’s rights under the
Constitution.
To help me distinguish between concepts of nationalism and
patriotism I turned to dictionary definitions.
Nationalism.
'Extreme pride in the history, culture and successes
of one's nation'. Chambers.
'Identification with one's own nation and support for its
interests, especially to the exclusion or detriment of the interests
of other nations'.
(Oxford.)
'Advocacy of, or support for the political independence of a
particular nation or people'. Oxford.
Patriotism.
'Loyalty to one's nation'.
(Chambers.)
'The feeling of loving your country more than any others and being
proud of it'.
(Cambridge.)
Groups like The English Defence League take the first two
definitions of nationalism to an extreme. President Trump does also
in pushing through protectionist legislation on the economy and in
his attitude to refugees.
Much of the world seems currently to reject the third definition
when we see current struggles for independence of Catalonians,
Biafrans, Kurds and Palestinians.
Patriotism comes into play when a country experiences war, takes
part in sporting events, or celebrating achievements. It needs to be
shown now in the UK as we move out of Europe, whether we voted to
leave or not, it is important that we show loyalty to our nation.
Patriotism can soon turn into a tribal form of nationalism in
sport though. It is possible to be loyal and patriotic to country or
club without insulting, or showing aggression towards the opposition.
It is worth pointing out that November 2nd. is the 100th.
Anniversary of the Balfour Declaration which led later to the
creation of Israel. The UK soon lost sight of their promise in
'the
establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people,
and will use their best endeavours to facilitate the achievement of
this object, it being clearly understood that nothing shall be done
which may prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing
non-Jewish communities in Palestine'. Here I struggle to define
myself as a patriot except that it should, like a true friend, be
possible to point out mistakes our country has made.
I will finish by looking at our National Anthem, some verses
contain some of the worst examples of nationalism. We usually only
sing the first verse but I remember Billy Connolly pointing out the
sixth verse which is an example the first of the
Oxford Dictionary
definitions of nationalism.
Lord grant that Marshall Wade
May by thy mighty aid
Victory bring
May he sedition hush
And like a torrent rush
Rebellious Scots to crush.
If we have to have this outdated anthem I prefer Verse 4 and
would be happier if that was retained and Verse 6 taken out.
Verse 4.
Lord make the nations see
That men should brothers be
And form one family
The wide world over.
It is our duty as citizens to be patriotic to our country but curb
the excesses of nationalism. The world is shrinking as travel becomes
easier and as 'no man can be an island unto himself', no nation can
survive without creating relations with other