Friday 8 November 2019

Northern Zionists Score Spectacular Own Goal!

by Chris Draper

WHEN “North-West Friends of Israel” (NWFOI) and other assorted Zionists tried to provoke a city-wide boycott of an “Interfaith Conference for Palestine” they got more than they bargained for when their bigoted and abusive behaviour was exposed and denounced by Chester community leader Roderick Heather MBE.

The free entry, open-to-all conference was due to begin at St Columba’s Church, Chester on 1st November 2019 but forty-eight hours before it convened a wolfpack spearheaded by NWFOI and led by Anthony Dennison and Raphi Bloom, bombarded Chester’s numerous church halls and community venues with telephone calls, emails and social media messaging all warning them not to host this conclave of “Anti-Semites, Holocaust Deniers and Hate-Speakers”.  Unfortunately for the bigots after they succeeded in bullying the Bishop of Shrewsbury into cancelling the church booking the Conference found an ideal alternative at Hoole Community Centre where the Chairman of the Trustees, Roderick Heather courageously withstood a barrage of intimidatory NWFOI communications.

Unlike the local Labour MP Chris Matheson who ignorantly obliged local reporters with prejudiced and ill-informed comments of the “We don’t want holocaust deniers in our town” type, Roderick Heather actually took the trouble to attend the conference as an observer and judge for himself whether this was indeed an anti-semitic event or rather, a free, open-minded conference which included criticism of Israeli State policy.

After spending a day at the Conference, Mr Heather informed those attending that he was very impressed by the content of speeches, quality of discussion and conduct of the meeting and assured everyone present that they would always be welcome to return to the Hoole Centre.  This contrasted with his conclusions about the behaviour of the NWFOI and to them he addressed the following message;

“Your intervention (and the various other coordinated extreme ones we received today) did nothing to help foster good community relations here in Chester or to improve the understanding and sympathy for the Jewish cause nationally in the UK.  The ill-informed and bigoted telephone and social media campaign that we have witnessed today is a disgrace.  It was unfounded and unnecessary and has done your cause much harm. Be aware that I am ensuring that as many people as possible (locally and nationally) are made aware of the vitriolic, verbal bullying we have been subjected to today.”
Roderick Heather MBE

Chairman Hoole Community Trust

The North’s Zionist lobby is demonstrably determined to intimidate anyone who sticks their head above the parapet and criticises Israel.  The tactic is to conflate criticism of Israel with anti-semitism. Jews who criticise Israel (like those who attended the Chester conference) are branded “self-hating Jews” and dismissed. Archbishop Tutu describes Israel as an apartheid state but merely to agree with him is sufficient grounds for anyone to be expelled from the Labour Party.  Free speech is a precious commodity that’s found a friend in Mr Heather and sinister enemies in NWFOI.  Perhaps Mr Dennison, Mr Bloom,  Mr Matheson or the Bishop of Shrewsbury would care to reply and offer a justification for their appalling behaviour but I rather think not for they evidently fear quiet, honest, open, reasoned debate.

************************

4 comments:

Tony Greenstein said...

Joseph O'Neill

Joseph,

Whilst I'm pleased the Zionists didn't stop your recent Chester Conference on Palestine I am deeply disappointed that you invited Gilad Atzmon, someone who has no connection with the Palestine solidarity movement in Britain and who is anti-Semitic. I am told that Revd. Stephen Sizer and Mick Napier among others turned down the invitation to speak as a result.

I have sent this statement to Derek Pattinson who emailed me regarding Atzmon.

"Gilad Atzmon is recognised as anti-Semitic and most Palestinians give him a very wide berth. It was therefore reckless and utterly counterproductive for the recent Chester Palestine conference to have him as an invited speaker. Anyone in any doubt should read Granting No Quarter: A Call for the Disavowal of the Racism and Antisemitism of Gilad Atzmon by Ali Abunimah, Omar Barghouti and many other well known and respected Palestinians and Arabs.

Atzmon, when you cut through his pseudo-philosophical nonsense is saying that Israel is what it is, not because it is a settler colonial state like many other similar states in the past, but because it is a Jewish state. In other words there is something about being Jewish tribally which leads to Israel. Hence why he calls me and other Jewish anti-Zionists anti-Zionist Zionists because in his 'logic' it follows that Jews are inherently Zionist. That to me is much what the Zionists also say.

Thus Atzmon rejects the settler-colonial analysis of Israel. He also opposes BDS and he has termed the academic boycott 'book burning'. He is totally self-obsessed and it was a serious mistake for him to have been invited and Joseph O'Neill who organised the conference should have known better and from what I know did know Atzmon's past."

See my Guide to the Sayings of Gilad Atzmon

Bargas Hatem said...

Dear Tony, until now I have admired your anti-zionist stance, found your blogs interesting and have objected to the Labour witch hunt against you.
What you say about Gilad Atzmon is utterly unfair. Yes,he objects to the state that occupies Palestine as being a "Jewish state", but can't you see the irony? That state is an Apartheid State that excludes Arabs and treats them as second class citizens, keeping them under siege. And he is right in saying: 'We are not objecting to Jews, but we are objecting to their racism'.
Gilad Atzmon has, amongst other topics,brought the right for Palestinian refugees to return to their homeland back into the debate, a point that you all ignore. You look on silently, while people are murdered for this demand and Jews all over the the world are granted 'Aliya'. Who is perpetrating racism here?
Free speech is a right for everyone and Gilad would not dream to deny it to you, even if he calls you an 'Anti-Zionist Zionist. It would be better to think about this term seriously, rather than hit back with the same old Zionist accusation of him being anti-semitc, something that is as alien to him as it is to most people, like yourself, accused of that label.

bammy said...

Tony Greenstein said... 'I am deeply disappointed that you invited Gilad Atzmon,'.

Does this mean the Tony is now seeking to no-platform Gilad Atzmon? If isn't he being a bit inconsistent?

Chris Knight said...

The stuff by Tony Greenstein is all perfectly factual.